This Atlantis Shuffle produced an 80% win rate (32-8) in Diamond, finishing with a #320 rank in Mythic.
On the play, this deck went 19-2 for a 90.5% win rate. On the draw, it went 13-6 for a 68.4% win rate.
80% Win Rate in Diamond
Diamond 4 into Diamond 2
Diamond 4 into Diamond 2 games can be seen below, as a screenshot from MTGA Assistant:
If there were 11 games where the other guy played some green, it turns out we lost only one of those 11. Which reminds me of this recent quote by Mike in Magic Secrets on whatsapp:
“Mostly I feel like if I see a forest they are probably going to lose – like idk 75%” – Mike Long
Diamond 2 into Diamond 1 – with 1 Caveat
Diamond 2 into Diamond 1 games can be seen below, as a screenshot from MTGA Assistant:
A tiny caveat is that the game against All-In was played in Diamond 1.
Diamond 1 into Mythic
Diamond 1 into Mythic games can be seen below, as a screenshot from MTGA Assistant:
Diamond 2 into Mythic Playlist
Diamond 2 into Mythic playlist can be found below. Our very own Adam Weinstein, who earned a top 8 in a 128 tourney very recently, mentioned on Magic Secrets whatsapp that this contains incredible reads. As watching my own replays is helpful for myself and for Adam, so do I hope it’s helpful for you too!
Win Rate vs Mono-Green and Green White
Win rate vs mono-green and green white can be seen below, as a screenshot from MTGA:
Note that these win rates include games from Platinum rank, from the days prior to getting into Diamond. Also note that this was platinum rank after Nathan Steuer and Christoffer Larsen sat down in the finals of Pro Tour Secrets of Strixhaven, as this month I started playing ranked on May 5.
#320 in Mythic, May 2026
#320 in Mythic during May 2026 season can be seen below, as a screenshot from MTG Arena:
80% Win Rate Atlantis Shuffle Decklists
Atlantis Shuffle decklists can be found below, as a screenshot from MTGA Assistant:
The version on the left is the one I played Diamond 4 into Diamond 2. The version on the right is the one I played Diamond 2 into Mythic. The version on the right has one more Floodpits Drowner, and one less Michelangelo, Weirdness to the 11.
Atlantis Shuffle decklist can be found below, as a text export from MTG Arena:
Deck
4 Botanical Sanctum (OTJ) 267
4 Breeding Pool (EOE) 251
3 Multiversal Passage (OM1) 181
4 Starting Town (FIN) 289
4 Ouroboroid (EOE) 201
4 Tishana’s Tidebinder (LCI) 81
1 Detect Intrusion (OM1) 28
4 Badgermole Cub (TLA) 167
1 Michelangelo, Weirdness to 11 (TMT) 121
4 Druneth, Reviver of the Hive (OM1) 136
1 Repulsive Mutation (MKM) 227
3 Mindspring Merfolk (DFT) 51
1 Spell Pierce (DFT) 64
3 Cenote Scout (LCI) 178
3 Gene Pollinator (EOE) 186
4 Llanowar Elves (M19) 314
3 Mockingbird (BLB) 61
4 Quandrix Charm (SOS) 217
1 Harmonized Trio (SOS) 52
1 Island (NEO) 295
1 Forest (NEO) 301
2 Floodpits Drowner (DSK) 59
